The Ghost King Fiction Review
Posted on October 9, 2009 by teampreston
Available at Amazon.com
Also available at DriveThruFantasy.com
The Ghost King: Transitions Book III, By R.A. Salvatore
(Advance Reader Copy)
Hardcover: 352 pages
Publisher: Wizards of the Coast (October 6, 2009)
When the Spellplague ravages Faerûn, Drizzt and his companions are caught in the chaos. Seeking out the help of the priest Cadderly–the hero of the recently reissued series The Cleric Quintet–Drizzt finds himself facing his most powerful and elusive foe, the twisted Crenshinibon, the demonic crystal shard he believed had been destroyed years ago.
I think one of the coolest parts of writing reviews is not only getting to read a lot of material, but to really get in to the nuts and bolts of how that material is “assembled”. In this case I have been fortunate to read a LOT of Forgotten Realms novel by R.A. Salvatore as well as others such as Paul Kemp. Having read all the “Drizzt Novels” to date, I can say with certainty that the author has improved his craft greatly over the years.
R.A. Salvatore, like any writer clearly has a deep relationship with many of his characters. While some writers are able to outline and crank out material in a mechanical fashion more often then not they go through a sort of adventure of their own; discovering the world and characters as they write. It’s like a journey for the characters as well as the writer. In doing so the author learns to love and hate characters and tries to share it with us…the readers.
I think it is a measure of success when the author is able to manipulate the heart-strings of the reader, and R.A. Salvatore has done a masterful job at this over the years. Some times more than others, I admit it. I don’t expect a baseball player to hit a home run every time at the plate. I don’t expect a writer to write “the perfect novel” every time either. Stephen King is a good example of this.
R.A. Salvatore has been building up steam throughout this whole series. Transitions. In the Transitions series we are seeing the tale of how Faerun is going through some massive changes. Much of the face of The Forgotten Realms will be different afterward. At the heart of this are changes in direction and flavor of D&D 4th Edition and the 4e Forgotten Realms setting.
Like it or not, love it or hate it, Wizards of the Coast owns D&D and the setting that these novels reside in, and they have mandated change.
Our intrepid author is responsible for writing novels explaining how we get from the Forgotten Realms we have all known for the past 25 years…to this new setting.
What does that mean for the author? It means that in the jump in time that occurs the vast majority of humans and short-lived races will have died and left some sort of legacy (or not). Many of the characters which have been so lovingly crafted will die. That means core protagonists (and antagonists) will be no more.
R.A. Salvatore in this series has been building this up, and I have to say, he has most certainly delivered.
Without spoiling the story for you, I’ll say that all the protagonists and antagonists have a rough ride through the story. The Spellplague is up-close and personal in this novel. Actually, previous to this novel I thought the Spellplague to be a little trite. A game designer’s tool to wipe the slate clean and start fresh. Salvatore put a “human” face on it, made it personal. Now I get it. Now I understand it and accept it and in the process understand how we can leave the previous edition’s Faerun for the new future.
I can’t help to feel sorry for the author in this. You can certainly feel the pain. You know something is coming. It’s like watching a train wreck…you just can’t look away. This is a book of heroism in the face of impossible odds. Acceptance of fate as well as stoic denial of it. It’s about loss…and hope.
There is only so much I can say about it. Usually I can drone on and on about this or that in a novel. Not this time. You have to read it for yourself. It’s good. Seriously. Probably R.A. Salvatore’s best work. I cried like a baby. It took several tries to get through the last dozen pages.
Review by Jeff Preston
Tags | forgotten-realms, ra salavatore, wotc
I agree wholeheartedly with your review. I can’t put into words the emotions I felt as I read through this wonderful piece of literature. I have read Salvatore’s works since the beginning and feel that I KNOW the characters within. I can’t imagine how hard it must have been to write it. To Mr.Salvatore: Thank you for years of your hard work to create such masterful works of art for so many years. I sometimes find myself trying to live up to the Drizzt Do’ Urden standard in my day to day life (morality wise). Thanks again!
Reply
I just read this yesterday, and I feel inclined to comment on R.A. Salvatore’s Ghost King. If you are a fan of R.A. Salvatore’s work, you will be pleased with the writing when Drizzt is on the scene. Fans of his Sellswords Trilogy will be pleased to see that Jarlaxle is back to add some depth to the plot. Cadderly and Danica are back in full swing, as is Pikel and Ivan. Their children are now grown up too, and to a certain extent, the book focuses a lot on Cadderly and Crew. Fans of Guen will be a bit dissapointed, only because the 500 pound panther isn’t mentioned much at all in the book, even when the odds seemed completely stacked against Drizzt.
It should be noted that R.A. Salvatore is my favorite author, and I enjoy everything I have read by him. This is definitely not his best book, but there are touches of brilliance as he brings out the emotion of the situation/events/relationships. I really would have liked to see more about Drizzt/Catti/Bruener. The book focused a bit too much on Cadderly for my liking. Still, a worthy effort, and the last 10 pages or so were very excellently done.
Reply
Bill Reply:
December 10th, 2009 at 3:03 pm
Just wondering, what is your favorite salvatore book??? I have read the entire “drizzt series” and “the highwayman” and the “sell sword series” any recommendations on where to start my next salvatore adventure??
Reply
Joshua Reply:
January 27th, 2010 at 10:26 am
Absolutely start with the Demon War series. There are 7 books starting with the Demon Awakens and ends with Mortalis. As much as I love the Drittz novels for there warm and fuzzy feeling they give me, like family at Christmas, the Demon War books are technically superior in writing style, depth, and meaning. I believe they are his flagship, and also possibly the best fantasy ever written since J.R.R Tolkien
Reply
It still amazes me that Drizzt fans are so thirsty for this character that they cannot pick up on the most simple and obvious failings of a terrible author. Salvatore is so lacking in his creativity that he can’t help but repeat himself constantly in his writing. Every characters reaction to every situation is “opening their eyes wide!” We have seen this before in his books with “600 pounds of panther” and “by the stones” so on and so on….A quarter of the way through the book you are hoping to not read the same lines again.
The dialogue for Bruenor is reduced to simply asking “elf?” time and time again and the majority of the book’s content consists of Cadderly and his children and nobody who is a Drizzt fan really cares about them. It’s a shame Salvatore doesn’t have the mind to create better dialogue for his characters, or to come up with a model for better story telling other than to deliver more emo garbage. The only saving grace for this book is Wulfgar is hardly mentioned. People who love this kind of cheap writing are the same ones who hunger for more Captain Kirk.
The Ghost King is weak.
Reply
R.A. Salvatore Reply:
October 27th, 2009 at 10:09 am
Why, Patrick, I think Jafis just called you stupid.
But then again, Jafis, so full of venom for me, has just confessed to reading them all…so, Jafis….DUH.
I’m not laughing at you, but I sure am laughing near you.
Bob
Reply
jafis Reply:
October 29th, 2009 at 3:59 am
I read all kinds of books and give an objective opinion. Something you obviously can’t do. You are not Salvatore, you are a fanboy who is all hurt by cutting criticism. Poor child!
I should expect nothing less from those who suck on the fodder.
Reply
R>A. Salvatore Reply:
October 29th, 2009 at 5:50 am
No, I’m actually R.A. Salvatore. Feel free to e-mail me at rasalvtore@AOL.com and I’ll be happy to respond.
And here, let me explain how this intertubey thing works to you. You can say whatever you want, of course. It’s your right, even though it really says more about you than about those you attack. And you can do it behind your internet spine, oh joy!
And I can laugh at you. And I am.
And by the way,”story telling” and “storytelling” are two different things, and you probably should learn the difference if you want to be taken seriously as someone so elevated and more sophisticated than those you sneer at down the end of your uplifted nose.
“…those who suck on the fodder”? Seriously? Good imagery there! I’m picturing a kid in farmer jeans walking barefoot down a road with a stalk of hay hanging out of his mouth. You should be a writer, really – or better yet, a critic!
Thanks for the laughs. Please, keep ‘em coming!
Bob
Monica Reply:
October 29th, 2009 at 5:55 am
At this point I’d like to step in and politely remind everyone to “play nice.”
Have to somewhat agree with the person above-I remember when Catti-brie was going on about something about Drizzt, after Salvatore had to say ‘Oh what a wonderful and perspective woman and beautiful woman!’ after-which really annoyed me-And I think he described Catti-brie more then made her do anything important .Shallow, really. But what do you expect? The story line is pretty much centered around Drizzt, and all the people who hate him/love him are included to add to him -_- . Its annoying for me because Drizzt, nor any of his companions/friends are my favorite character in this series. Bad for me because this series was probably made for Drizzt.
Though the thing is, the story is able to make the reader make it to the end and wish for more. Its fun to read, though Salvatore is pretty much making Drizzt his only selling point for fans. You kind of fail to realize no matter how much you rat on it, readers who have realized the ‘truth’ won’t stop reading the series at all.
Reply
The dialogue was indeed lacking, so much so that i was able to read through this book in a few days without the need to stop and contemplate what i have just read..unlike previous works by RAS..
The story line on the other hand “for me” was excellent!! with a few exceptions.
Reply
by far, it brings full circle into the new forgotten realms world. My biggest question for Mr. Salvatore is: Is this the last we have seen of Drizzt and his companions or are more works on the way. I have put so many years into your writings and eagerly anticipate every new release. Regardless of what some hack reviewers write. Your writings hit me with these characters on a deep emotional level. I cry just thinking about the ending of the story.
Reply
R>A. Salvatore Reply:
October 29th, 2009 at 5:51 am
No, it’s not the last book. I’m working on the last book currently under contract right now, but I’m in discussions with Wizards about what will come next.
Peace,
Bob
Reply
jafis Reply:
November 3rd, 2009 at 1:26 am
Hopefully you will learn to stop repeating yourself in your books and learn to give your characters the attention and color they are due. Maybe a few refresher courses in college might do you some good as well as learning what professionalism is.
Send your sample writings to me “Bob” and I will correct them for you.
jafis@comcast.net
Reply
Monica Reply:
November 3rd, 2009 at 3:46 pm
At this point, I would appreciate no further comments regarding this exchange. Any further derogatory comments will be deleted. I asked for polite communication, and this is no longer “polite.”
Alex Reply:
February 2nd, 2010 at 8:40 pm
Just have to say that the events of this last book are a great start to a perfect ending for the series. If you keep it going after maybe one more book I think it’s going to dry up very quickly.
Reply
I just finished the book. I first read Crystal Shard in 1988. Obviously, I have been following these books for over 20 years. There are many things I would like to comment on but would refrain from spoiling any part of the plot for those that have yet to read it.
I was not disappointed with the book. As others have mentioned, there is quite a spectrum of emotions the reader goes through during this book. I was just left a tad confused, but with the underlying feeling that victory is not always joyous. I am glad to hear that there are additional books coming. I felt like there was much more to tell.
Reply
I finished The Ghost King a few days ago, and I loved everything about the book, as I have since I first started reading Mr. Salvatore’s work when I was 13. I think your books put forth a concept of morality that I have embedded in my day to day life for years. I have yet to read any book, from any author that has affected so many readers personally. I am glad to hear this is not the last book, and will truly be sad when I have read the last page of the last book.
Some people simply love everything about Mr. Salvatore’s works.
Reply
Bob,
If it is indeed you, Mr. Salvatore-What a fantastic book. You are my favorite author.
This is easily my favorite book in the “Drizzt Sagas”. I have yet to read the Demon War books.
The book was very emotional and very well written, especially the last 20-30 pages or so. It is one of those books, stories, movies, etc. that touches you and moves you so much, you simply can NOT stop thinking about it.
Thank you, Mr. Salvatore.
Reply
Rune Reply:
November 19th, 2009 at 5:57 pm
After reading The Ghost King I want to go back and read the Demon Wars books over again. The way that the books followed the lives (and in some cases deaths) of the characters in Demon Wars made them feel so very real.
Reply
First of all, Jafis stop being a ignorant prick.
And second, I would like to say that I loved every second of this book until the two chapters. I feel empty now.
Reply
jafis Reply:
November 5th, 2009 at 1:08 am
- Comment Deleted
Reply
Wow Jafis, enjoy that spam
Reply
jafis Reply:
November 5th, 2009 at 1:03 am
-Comment Deleted
Reply
Matt-M-McElroy Reply:
November 5th, 2009 at 6:40 am
And with that you are finished.
As the owner of the Flames Rising site I’m telling you to walk away from this one.
If you have a problem with the book or author take it somewhere else. This is no longer the place for your little rants.
Reply
i love all of your books that ive read… im actually rereading the whole sereies… but anyway is there really only one more book left?? and dont listen to that fool i never felt like i knew characters like i did after reading your books. I just dont think i was ready for what came out with that book
Reply
I’ll admit before I even read the book I was expecting a whole different story. I was thinking of a reemergence of Valindra with a resurrected Greeth seeking revenge or something along those lines… kind of makes sense considing the book title. Besides, it’s a mystery to me to have her turned into a lich and not only play no role in the Pirateking but disappear altogether…. so she has to make a reappearance right? Nope lol
I did enjoy the Ghostking but felt a little lost while reading it. I haven’t played D&D for over 10 years so the weakening weave kind of threw me. I am hoping there will be another in the series though because SO many questions… about the open rifts…. did the ghost king really escape(not sure since he flew away) and obviously about a certain 3 characters and I’ll leave it at that. Then again, any Salvatore fan has probably picked this book up the first day it was available so I don’t think I am spoiling anything lol
Anyway keep up the good work Salvy if thats really you and keep them coming.
Reply
joe k Reply:
November 8th, 2009 at 8:53 pm
i think if you would like some answers that you should read unclean and that trilogy because it explains the open rifts in the books, even though it isnt written by R.A Salvotore
Reply
I loved the book, i couldn’t put it down, but it leaves me with one question, will this book be that last of drizzt?
Reply
Mr. Salvatore i have read all of your books and have fallen in love with the stories along with the characters. I think your as good if not better then j.r.r Tolkien and i would like to personally thank you for stories and for giving me something to look forward too. At the end of The Ghost King i felt drizzt’s pain, i couldnt imagine how you felt after this book.
Reply
You are the reason why I started reading books.
You are a major reason behind my medical recovery.
You are a major reason behind my recovery from prescription drug abuse.
As simple and corny as the above statement(s) may seem it’s 100% truth. I own every published work of yours, as someone who at first struggled at a young age to pick up books and read them (because of ADD and other learning issues) to the countless free hours I have had while dealing with cancer recovery I would not be where I am today as a whole without you and your magnificent works! For thank I can only say Thank You! from the very bottom of my heart. You saved a life.
NOTE TO SELF: Find location / fly to your next in store appearence so I can shake your hand.
Reply
Joshua Reply:
January 27th, 2010 at 10:46 am
I know how you feel RJ. I was alone and in a deep pit of depression when I first discovered Bob’s books. Within a year a read everything he published to date. I can say with 100% certainty that his stories lifted me out of that dark era. His books provided me with a safe place to go and recover. God bless you Bob.
Reply
If it is Salvatore, then great job. Sure, mabe there wasn’t much dialouge, but here’s my view- if your wife (in Drizzt’s case) or your daughter (in Brienor’s) is in a magically induced coma along with a dear friend who you have shed blood, sweat, and tears with over a few decades of life and the both of them are experiencing unspeakable horrors…now is not the time for witty dialouge or introspection. Now is the time for a nuke. ‘Cept you don’t have one. You have a dark elf who can eat Rambo for breakfast. So be it.
Reply
P.S.
Not to ride in on Rj’s coattails, but do you still do book signings and, if so, will they ever take you into or near Houston, Texas? Or even just Texas?
Reply
Definitely a great book. I personally found the repetition of certain dialogue to be necessary. As Ri pointed out, sometimes situations provide a loss for words. I think that the repetition of “elf” for example just helps give insight into Bruenor’s mind, my opinion anyways. If Bruenor somehow came out with new, advanced dialogue I feel it would break with the consistency that was given throughout the entire series.
I truely hope there are many more of these books to come, currently on my re-read of the series, just finished book 10, and I must say that even though I know the story already, I find myself in as much if not more anticipation than the first time I read through the story.
Reply
i have read the every book from the crystal shard until the pirate king and i have never ever felt any tinge of disappointment from Mr. Salvatore. I have played DnD since 3rd edition and a lot of my characters have been inspired by the companions of the hall. though the ghost king has yet to reach my shores (i’m from the Philippines), i am eager to get my copy and i am confident that this last installment (for transitions)will never be a disappointment. or else bregan d’aerthe should go bankcrupt. i pray that this would not be your last work Mr. Salvatore…please continue with your stories that inspire..til our swords do part!
Reply
Hmmm..Something has been bothering me for a few months, though..will there ever be a sideseries about Zaknafein? I mean, the only reason not to do it would be either Salvatore isn’t in the mood, or that it would be pretty difficult. Still, i’d buy it in a hearbeat.
Also, since there will be another book apparently as it’s under contract, I look forward to reading more about Drizzt’s story…and horefully Jaraxle will continue to cause trouble.
Reply
it wasn’t bad. i think folks are right, a lot of his work is relatively repetitive and the rather mundane…..but i like the story, the concept, and the characters. i’ve read them all since i was a kid. some a few times. i do wonder if drizzt is going to find another woman, lol. that one elf woman from the lone drow? and is artemis fully out of the story?
Reply
Fist I loved the book, I read it in one day, and may be rereading it soon. There are a few things that threw me. Not being a DnD player I guess I was hoping to learn more about the spell plague, and the failing weave. A more detailed description, but I know R.A didn’t really have any power over this. I was happy to finally see the characters from the sellswords saga finally reunite. Though the way the 3 came together to become the Ghost King was slightly strange for me, but still very entertaining. I’d agree the dialogue was a bit dry in this one, and Jarlaxle just doesn’t seem like the same character I grew to love during the sellswords series. I didn’t think we’d see the return of Artemis Entreri, but I still held some small amount of hope. We did get to see his name once at least. I hope to see him in the future, by then he’ll be old, but maybe he’ll be the leader of his own guild, or even training maybe a grandson or something. I wanted to learn more about Athrogate and his past. I was sad at how little we saw Guen, but I was very very happy with the friendship that was developing between Athrogate and Pwent, lol long lost father and son! Ok not really, but it’d been great. I almost feel Cadderly should have been on the cover, because I believe he was the main character of this book in place of Drizzt who almost seems to play a supporting character roll in parts of the book. But I did love the book, I couldn’t put it down. I have high hopes for the future. I’d love to see the prologue from the Orc king turned into a book. One thing I had to chuckle about, was how many times the word “catastrophe” was used.
Reply
I’d just like to add that I’ve been reading these books since the age of five when I first picked up the Crystal Shard in 1990, and ever since R.A has kept my imagination fueled, and looking forward to each new installment. His work has inspired to my own writing, and hope to see the return of the characters we’ve grown up loving soon.
Reply
I honestly think the series should keep going, and there should never be an ending…Also, do you think Wulfgar will make a return?
Reply
Haven’t yet given this one a read (waiting to see if someone already got it for me for Christmas, lol), but I’m looking forward to it. I thought Transitions started off a bit bland (or it could be that there was actually less focus on Obould, who rocked out hard in Hunter’s Blades), but it picked up pretty well.
The Pirate King was awesome, though. I think if I ever run another FR campaign I’m obliged to use Arklem Greeth (and what’s-her-face-that-also-got-lich’d, too) as an antagonist–he was just deliciously horrid.
I’m going to have to second (or probably second-millionth, ’cause I know this has come up before) the notion that, if Salvatore walks a bit off from Drizzt’s own story again, some kind of prequel-story featuring Jarlaxle and Zaknafein in their glory days in Menzoberranzan would be awesome.
Overall, it seems to me that, whatever gripes there are about Salvatore’s writing, it kind of gets lost amidst the fact that this isn’t meant to be some kind of classic literature. If it were food, it would be a cheeseburger. A really GOOD cheeseburger.
Reply
Just finished The Ghost King. Overall, I really enjoyed it. But to be honest, I felt that most of the characters felt a bit 2-dimensional this time around, especially Jarlaxle. I hope the next one really delves into the personalities we all know and love a bit more.
For me, I just found there’s been a bit too much all-out battles, and not enough personal insights into the characters in some of these past few novels.
The ending was a heart-breaker, but something tells me we haven’t seen the end of Catt and Regis.
You’re a fantastic writer Mr. Salvatore, I hope the Drizzt series continues on for many more books!
Reply
Well this book has officially succeeded in depressing me for 48 hours after reading it and the feeling still isn’t gone.
*spoiler alert*
So unless I’m missing something critical, Catti-brie and Regis, because of their condition, didn’t advance into the afterlife, but are stuck in a state of bliss in a glen on Toril. So Drizzt isn’t going to unite with her in the afterlife…ughhhh. I was anticipating a sad ending, but dayum, this makes Gone with the Wind look like the end of Beauty and the Beast.
Reply
In my opinion I feel that though Drizzt is the hero of this series it is the depth of his rivals and companions that has really made this series shine. By far I would have to say the Icewind dale trilogy was the best book I have read of the forgotten realms where a group of characters were really though out and developed and brought together – and their depth in that series allowed them to be carried on through dozens of more books. I have thoroughly enjoyed all of the series even the offshoots about Jarlaxle and Artemis as they showed Salvatore’s unique character development and writing styles and the character growth throughout the books.
Not to be rude or come across in the wrong way but I feel that the pirate king and the ghost king have been much weaker than the rest of the series. The characters we had all come to know and enjoy reading about were hardly themselves. Bruenor and Drizzt and Regis were the only ones really mentioned throughout both books and like others had mentioned above it felt like their dialogue and personalities had just left them. Even Drizzt’s thoughts between chapters made him seem like he was kind of in a daze throughout the entire book of the ghost king. I did not mind the cleric quintet either so the presence of older companions did not bother me as much though the book turned out to be mostly about Cadderly and Jarlaxle with Drizzt being along for the ride.
I can see many possibilities for future adventures in this series though I really hope we have not seen the last of the companions of the hall. If nothing else I felt the ending was half that which was rewarded to Wulfgar back when he “died”. The ending of the Ghost King could almost have been summarized as “and all the cool characters were put in limbo, and the others cried” where I feel they each deserved a whole lot more based on the history and importance of them all on the series. Even Cadderly could have received something a little more finishing than an god walking in circles forever, some neat spell scars even might have spiced things up a bit.
Reply
Daniel Reply:
December 21st, 2009 at 11:49 am
I agree totally on Dennis comment. I would have wrote the same. I have all the books of Drizzt + sellsword + Chaos curse + Spider Queen 6 books etc… Big fan of Forgotten realms. What I could add to Dennis comment is that this book lack of pages. Some stuff would have need more explanations. And the way those caracters….that blue lightning stuff…lack of imagination. I understand that changes were needed, and the book is full of it, but…well I’m not the author. I love R.A. Salvatore Books, but this one is not my favorite. I enjoyed it but not as much as others.
Reply
Finished the book today and I loved it. It was above and beyond anything I have ever read. Never have I felt anything so profound from a book and nearly broke down in the middle of class when I finished it. With Drizzt’s new found rage, is he going to finish off Entreri? It feels like so many things are left open at the end of The Ghost King. And I wanna see Entreri one last time lol. Can’t wait for the final book. Hope it blows this one right out of the water, good luck and Godspeed.
Reply
i love all of salvatore’s work .have read all the drizzt books many times over the ghost king was the best of the transition series. also i have two boxer dogs named drizzt and catti-brie. i love the forgotten realms,but i don’t like the spell plague direction. oh well role with the punches-thanks
Reply
In review, I’d say the book as a whole makes an excellent story, but more so the storytelling than with immersion. It seems the goal of ‘transitions’ was to show change: change in environment, in the characters, in emotions, and in the world; but there were some things that bothered me about many of the changes.
The conflict and “peace” between the orcs and dwarves was done well: ending in a kind of half-trusted stalemate. In contrast, the seeming evolution of Jarlaxle from Chaotic Neutral to Chaotic Good does not seem viable and many of his actions in the book were contrary to his nature. Do not get me wrong: people can change, but only gradually over time and only within the confines that their nature allows. Some attempt was made to point out the selfish reasons for his decisions, but it was clear that such reasons were really just to fool himself.
Another inconsistency was the intervention of Bregen De’arthe. Such an organization will take the least costly and least noticeable approach of gaining knowledge and resources. Their greatest gain would be information about the failing weave and converegence with the shadow plane, but there was very little that they did to actually gain knowledge on either of these fronts. (In truth, their intervention to save a bunch of refugee humans seemed similar to the Jurassic Park 3 ending where the military just shows up and fixes everything)
For anyone who is not extremely familiar with Drizzt and his companions, I believe there would be a great loss of translation of Breunors grunts. The fact is that the two friends know each other so well that words are no longer necessary; but for someone reading who is only somewhat familiar with the characters, it was not nearly enough. It also seems that Bruenor took a back-seat, where if he had been acting to character he would be in an uncontrollable battle frenzy due to his daughter’s condition.
To any future purchaser: This book an is an easy green light. Fun, fantasy, fear, and future; but I would recommend at least reading Icewind Dale if you have not already done so in order to grasp the nature of the main character. There is a lot more emotion entwined in this book than many of the others in the Drizzt serieses, but much of the real story is lost if you do not have an adequate knoweledge of the characters.
To the author:
I’d say you should take a break and read someone else’s story, such The Lord of the Rings; then read your own Icewind Dale from cover to cover before continuing with any new Drizzt books. There is a certain thirst for danger and adventure that Drizzt has lost as well as wisdom, perhaps it is time for him to be reminded of it.
If you are open to thoughts: this book has left our hero more vulnerable than he has been since his birth. As with real people, he would not venture beyond the limits of his nature, but he once held a powerful alter-ego that may try to fill the void. There is also the business with the weave that above the changes taking place leave most of the world in fear: perhaps a fear much like that which was constant in Menzoberranzan, where the clever are able to manipulate the fearful.
Reply
I have read his books for so long that I can honestly say that when I bought the Ghost King that it wouldnt be the last and I will keep on reading as long as R.A. Salvatore is willing to crank them out. I find that whatever genre i read be it western or scifi or fantasy that i cannot get under the skin of a character like i can when reading the story of Drizzt. I believe that Salvatore it arguably one of the greatest authors of our time and to any and all nay-sayers…if you do not like the way he writes his books then why have you read so far into his stories im very sure that if you dont like it that there are many more authors that can give you what you want in a book
Reply
i guess to clear things up with the blue lighting stuff people would have to read the the books undead and unclean for thats were all of it started and it explains it well.
Reply
First off let me say that I am a fan of Salvatores and have been since I was 10. This book while entertaining left me strangly unfufilled, which is completely new to me. I won’t give any spoilers but I just can’t believe the ending. Granted I didn’t expect it to happen that way, but I don’t agree with it. As I stopped following the timeline in FR back when I stopped running campaigns, ie Time of Troubles, I never heard about the failing weave. I’m curious to see whats in store for Drizzt most definately, and looking forward to the return of “The Hunter,” cause I’m sure his rage will put him there.
Reply
I just finished The Ghost King, and although it was good, I also was very depressed by the ending, and have been thinking about it for several days. I am married, and cannot even think of life without my wife, whom I live for. I must say, though, that my favorite story line was the Orc King, which was pure genious in creating a brilliant, powerful Orc who wanted peace. I have not read a better story in many years.
Reply
I don’t think I’ve read every book Salvatore’s put out, but I’ve certaintly tried to. And I stuck to this trilogy since the first one came out, only not finished reading Ghost King as I got it as a christmas present, and had lots of things to do this week. However I’ve almost fully read it in the last 2 days, and judging from the reviews it seems the last couple dozen pages will be major, but from what I’ve read so far it’s a great peice of work.
As for the people asking why Bruenor’s dialogue is so repetitive, or why everyones eyes are always widening, consider the guys daughters just gone braindead and he’s got nowhere to turn to fix it. Not much to say after you hit a point like that in your life.
And the repetitive responses to monsters popping out, well, the book could be less repetitive if they all started saying random things every time a new black fleshy thing pops out, but then it just wouldn’t seem realistic, people don’t do “something different” every time some unexpected figure appears suddenly, infact if you watch people, you’ll notice they usual do the exact same thing, whether it’s punch it reflexively, or jump and say “oh!”, it’s not usually a roll of the dice to which reaction they’ll have.
Looking forward to your future works Salvatore.
Reply
Having never played D&D in my life, or read any other Forgotten Realms books other than Salvatore’s, the whole Spellplague plot line sort of went completely over my head, I didn’t understand it, and I didn’t care about it, which made it sort of tough to follow.
The Ghost King plot, however, was very entertaining, especially the return of Hephaustus.
My main issue with the book was mentioned already, but the send-off for the now-departed characters was incredibly weak, especially since one of them was entirely absent from the Pirate King as well. I don’t think either of the two main ones even had single line of dialogue in this book. The problem is, with a year plus going by since I read the last book, I had no reason to really miss either character.
Hopefully the next book focuses more on the Obould-Bruenor dynamic and brings in some of the political intrigue that made his DemonWars series so phenomenal. Not to mention that Obould is probably the single greatest new character in the series since Jarlaxle.
Reply
I have to say, this has probably been my favorite work of Salvatore’s. The ending made me cry like I haven’t since the end of Harry Potter 7. I’ve been a huge fan of all things Salvatore for the last 10ish years, when I discovered the Icewind Dale books.
To all those who complain about the “repetitive nature” of the dialogue, it’s called consistency. Why would it make sense to have the characters shuffle their dialects every book?
Reply
I would just like to add that I have enjoyed all of the R.A. Salvatore book I have read. Being in the military and deployed they have really made the time go by quickly. Ending of Ghost King really hits you. Hopefully there will a Transitions IV.
Reply
I liked the story. A lot. I seemed to adequatly tie up a lot of dangly bits for me.
I didn’t really find the main characters much different than I’d imagine them during such a crisis.
Sure J had changed and has also undergone a lot of personal growth since this parting with Atremis.
I sincerly hope that ‘anything at touches’ the glen destroys it. Kind of incentive not to do so as pehaps it’s Drizzt’s and Jarlaxle’s goal now to learn this and to cope with the fallout.
I have to put it in writing that I will be passionatlly pissed! if this is just another ‘dead person gstting resurected in some smarmy manner to take away the importance and consequences of their death.
Reply
Really enjoyed the book. Reading some of these, and other comments from other sites, concerning whether or not Catti-brie and Regis are truly dead is really interesting. Some have commented that the way things were left was so that the characters could somehow return, and the commentors view this as a bad thing. For me, and I think many others, I think such an outcome would be preferred. Frankly, I don’t read these books for the realism. It is a world unlike ours in which our parents, siblings, significant others, and children don’t have to die. I find it nice to escape to such a world. It is nice to sometimes have the heart strings pulled and to realize that everything will be alright in the end and that the characters who we have spent so much time with will, in a way, always be there.
I hope those in charge of Forgotten Realms don’t damage what is good about these characters just in order to advance the Forgotten Realms world and sell new versions of the D&D franchise.
Reply
Love the book! Very emotional book compared to the past books, seemed more real to me. The book really let the fans realize that the characters in this series are not invincable. Although i do not like when an author kills off characters, i do realize that it is sometimes required. I have loved all of Salvatore’s books, not just the Drizzt series. It really amazes me that there are people out there like “jafis” that have the balls to critisize a VERY successful author like Savatore, its just so sad. When he write a series of books and makes the NEW York Times Best Seller List, then you are allowed to critisize. Thank you RA Salvatore for many years of great reading!
Reply
Is this supposed to be the last book about the Companions of the Hall? The way it ended seemed open ended to me but at the same time it felt as though I was say goodbye to them, that I wont be seeing them again for a while. While I realize that focusing on just one character can be unwise for Salvatore, and that he needs to work on other characters as well I really hope that more books about The Companions of the Hall will be published.
Reply
I just finished the Ghost King. I could barely get through the last few pages because of the tears…
It was a real treat to watch Athrogate and Pwent teaming up to “murder ‘em to death”. And what a team Jaraxle and Dritzz make! Very cool!. In fact I would love to see an adventure with the above four plus Artemis. That would be a doozy.
Bob, if you read this, I just want you to know I feel for you man! This must have been a hard book to write. I almost sensed that you were pressured to write the spell plague into your novels, and were not real happy about it. But you did a fabulous job anyway. And as hard as it was for me to have to watch beloved characters die, I need my emotional fix again!
I’m going to re-read the entire Demon War again.
Thank you Bob, you are a true gift to the world.
Reply
It felt almost as if the last 30 novels were a buildup to this last one and the message you get. After all of the resurrections and close calls that we’ve seen, the feeling that the protagonists are immortal sort of rubs off on you. And I think that, whether or not it was his intention, this last book does a complete spin and you get a strong reminder of the truth of mortality.
Reply
Admittedly I haven’t read all the Drizzt books. I don’t have a particular emotional connection with any of the characters in this book. But I did notice a few things.
Salvatore continues his tradition of making enemies seem like no real threat at all. Caderly’s kids smite down hundreds of zombies with no apparent effort, despite having never been in combat before that day. Sure, Salvatore makes an effort to say that the sheer numbers make the situation hopeless. But it doesn’t feel hopeless.
The same can be said about the battles with the Ghost King himself. All Salvatore talks about is how the heroes are tearing into him and how he fails to hit any of them with any real effect. And yet their struggle is hopeless. I have to hand it to Salvatore. It takes real talent to make a dracolich seem like no real threat.
I’m disapointed that Obould, who like someone said earlier is the best new character in the series, recieved only a mention. I’m disapointed that Bruenor and Athrogate’s dialogue was confined to “eh?” “whaddya know, elf?” and “Bhwahaha!” respectively.
And Cadderly. Dear god. How many times did he have to exlaim, both internally and externally, what a “strange journey” it had been through age? He got old really fast building the church and started getting younger afterwards. That is it. Granted, that isn’t exactly normal. But it did not require four or five repeating dialogues saying how strange it was with virtualy know variation.
The ending seemed fairly rushed getting them to that little field. And it generally didn’t make a whole lot of sense. Drizzt’s goddess rewards him by sending his wife and his best friend to what might as well be a living hell with pleasent decorations?
It wasn’t a terrible book. I’ve read much worse. But it was not great. And I didn’t cry.
Reply
Enjoyed the book. My favorite in Transitions had to be The Pirate King. That doesn’t seem like the popular choice here but Robillard kicking the crap out of that lich was pure awesomeness. I have believed for sometime now that the Companions of the Hall needed a little shaking up — you always felt like they would be safe and for a long time that’s exactly what you wanted, them to be secure. But years and years later, even though of course you won’t miss a book, they kind of left you (well, me) with a kind of dull feeling. Now, I’m ready and waiting for the next book – eagerly. I want to know how the companions cope. I admit, I cried
Two questions:
Did anyone else feel kind of robbed with the utter lack of dialouge for our two beloved characters? I almost felt cheated that they had absolutely no dialogue until the devastating end.
Is it me or is this whole Spellplague thing confusing to the reader? I found it’s use to be jarring in a way where Catti and Regis were concerned and I still have no idea how Cadderly became The Ghost King. I thought the dragon was called that because he posessed the shard.
Reply